Nicola Gobbo Sues Police for Damages as Former Informant
Former gangland lawyer turned police informant Nicola Gobbo is taking strict measures to protect her safety as she sues police for damages caused by her outing. Nicola Maree Gobbo launched legal action against the State of Victoria and 12 named police officers alleging their negligence damaged her health and career. Ms Gobbo was exposed as a police informer, known as Lawyer X, in December 2018 after a High Court ruling and has since gone into hiding. The case returned before the Supreme Court of Victoria on Monday for the first day of the judge-only trial, listed to run for four weeks.
Ensuring Safety During Legal Proceedings
- Ms. Gobbo’s barrister, Tim Tobin SC, requested strict measures to ensure her safety when she gives evidence
- He proposed that she give evidence remotely using a computer, with her video restricted to just lawyers and the judge
- Concerns about security associated with her image were raised, prompting the need for additional precautions
- Ms. Gobbo is not required to give any evidence about her current whereabouts in open court to protect her safety
Legal Arguments and Defense
- Ms. Gobbo alleges she was "induced" to become an informer and was owed a duty of care
- The State of Victoria argues that she provided information voluntarily and any unlawful conduct was her own
- Issues of confidentiality and legality surrounding Ms. Gobbo’s actions are central to the case
Preliminary Matters in Court
- The court addressed preliminary matters, including a subpoena made by Ms. Gobbo’s legal team to the Office of Public Prosecutions
- Justice Richards deemed the subpoena "oppressively broad" and not serving a legitimate forensic purpose
- The legal proceedings are ongoing, with further developments expected
Impact and Repercussions
- Ms. Gobbo’s involvement as a police informer has raised questions about the integrity of criminal convictions
- The Royal Commission into the Management of Police Informants found that over 1000 convictions could have been tainted by her actions
- The case highlights the complex interplay between legal ethics, law enforcement, and personal safety
In conclusion, the legal battle between Nicola Gobbo and the police forces in Victoria sheds light on the intricate relationships within the legal system. The ramifications of her role as a police informant go beyond individual cases, potentially affecting the credibility of numerous convictions. This case underscores the importance of transparency, accountability, and ethical considerations in the administration of justice. As the proceedings continue, it will be crucial to analyze the outcomes not just for the parties involved but also for the broader implications on legal practices and societal trust in the legal system.