The recent surge in luxury goods stocks, driven by optimism over China’s stimulus, may not be as solid as investors hope, according to analysts at Goldman Sachs Group Inc. In a note released Tuesday, Goldman’s Louise Singlehurst downgraded Gucci-owner Kering SA to a “sell” rating, expressing doubts about the short-term impact of China’s economic measures on high-end consumer spending.
“The recent rally in luxury stocks is built on shaky ground,” Singlehurst wrote. “The stimulus in China is unlikely to translate into increased demand for luxury goods in the near term, especially given the cautious outlook for consumer confidence.”
HSBC Holdings Plc analyst Erwan Rambourg echoed these concerns, highlighting that the recovery in Chinese luxury consumption will take time. “The road to a full rebound in China’s luxury market is likely to be long and gradual,” Rambourg stated.
Despite last week’s gains in the luxury sector, Goldman’s proprietary basket of European luxury goods makers remains down 16% from its peak in mid-March. This reflects broader concerns about the sustainability of the market rally.
Goldman Sachs is especially wary of brands like Kering, which are undergoing major turnarounds. Shares of Kering have dropped 37% year-to-date, with the company’s flagship brand Gucci facing challenges in repositioning its portfolio. While Gucci aims to shift its focus to more timeless, “evergreen” fashion, the current environment—characterized by weak store traffic and low consumer confidence, particularly in China—makes this a tough goal to achieve.
“The luxury market, especially brands like Kering that are in transition, faces significant headwinds. Depressed store traffic and cautious consumers, particularly in key regions like China, make it difficult to see a strong recovery in the near future,” Singlehurst added.
Expanded Analysis:
The luxury goods market is highly dependent on consumer confidence and discretionary spending, both of which remain fragile, particularly in China, a key growth market. Despite recent government stimulus aimed at boosting economic activity, it may take longer for these measures to trickle down to the luxury sector, which often relies on affluent customers feeling secure enough in their financial situation to make large purchases.
For investors, this creates both a challenge and an opportunity. While stocks like Kering are down significantly this year, this also presents a buying opportunity for those with a longer-term view. Should the turnaround at Gucci succeed in creating more demand for its “evergreen” products, Kering could see significant upside. However, in the short term, Goldman’s caution suggests that the market could remain volatile.
Investors should consider whether they are willing to ride out a potentially difficult period for luxury goods in exchange for long-term gains. The uncertainty surrounding China’s consumer recovery makes this a high-risk, high-reward play. Additionally, with other brands in the luxury space also facing challenges, it is crucial to assess whether broader market conditions will provide support for a rebound in the near future.
👉Explore AI-powered Automated Trading Today! Register for a free trial now!
✅Read about the automated trading software on Investing.com
